Agri. Minister Sharad Pawar is responsible for ‘Desi Bt’ Cotton Seeds fiasco
Nagpur- Dated 2nd January 2012
Now it’s official that Agri. Minister Sharad Pawar’s ill-motivated intentions are behind ICAR’s DDG S K Dutta’s forcible order to Central Institute of Cotton Research (CICR) stop commercial sale of so called ‘Desi Bt’ Cotton Seeds because of it’s rate for Rs. 200 per 2 kg bag as against Rs 1150 per 450 gm bag of Monsanto’s Bt.cotton seed whxh will be big hurdle for US seed giant Monsanto to create it’s monopoly ,there should be CBI probe of whole episode as the fact that ‘Desi Cotton seed’ of CICIR is fraud as it is originated from Genes provided after official bilateral agreement between ICAR and US MNC Monsanto , Kishor Tiwari of Vidarbha Jan Andolan Samiti, a farmers’ advocacy group who are documenting Bt.cotton crop failure and farmers suicides in vidarbha since 2005 urged Indian PM today in a press release today.
‘We are shocked to see news appearing in 2012 that Desi Bt’ Cotton Seeds having developed its own by Central Institute of Cotton Research (CICR) was a hoax and betrayal with farmers but those who are digging out the issue are on pay roll of US MNC Monsanto having visited the world on he company expenses hence the there reporting is biased and divert recent failure of American Bt.cotton seed in 122 lakhs hector in India those who talking about fraudulent activities ICAR and Indian Agriculture versities where refuting same allegations leveled by us 2009 ,in fact Agri. Minister Sharad Pawar is responsible for ‘Desi Bt’ Cotton Seeds fiasco and he should take responsibly and resign over issue’ Tiwari added.
‘All disputed decisions taken by ICAR or Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) in UPA region has strongly provide roots of suspicion of mala-fide interest of Agri. Minister Sharad Pawar ,hence we demand white paper over all ICAR and GEAC activities that ruined cotton agrarian economy in name of genetic revolution’ Tiwari urged.
Vidarbha cotton farmers urged India's Govt. to come clean on recent reported controversy of Hyped ‘Desi Bt’ Cotton Seeds having developed its own by Central Institute of Cotton Research (CICR) and Agriculture universities having spent hundred of crores over so called research which has put ICAR in Bt cotton (genetically modified) variety has taken an embarrassing turn with an RTI inquiry by two scientists revealing how the University of Agriculture Sciences (UAS) at Dharwad went ahead brushing aside all precautions to produce an indigenous variety working on a gene originally patented by Monsanto, Kishor Tiwari of Vidarbha Jan Andolan Samiti, a farmers’ advocacy group who are documenting Bt.cotton crop failure and farmers suicides in vidarbha since 2005 informed in a press release today.
“It is true that in 2009, the Indian Council of Agriculture Research (ICAR) had decided to stop the sale of Bikaneri Narma Bt Cotton seed marketed state owned seed corporation MAHABEEJ as an “completely indigenous Bt variety”,having failed to give any positive result . Bikaneri Narma was released for farmers as BN Bt by Central Institute for Cotton Research (CICR) in 2009. It was reported by CICR Director Keshav Kranthi that DESI Bt.cotton seeds will be available for Rs 200 per 2 kg bag as against Rs 1150 per 450 gm bag of Monsanto’s Bt.cotton seed currently sold by national and multinational companies like Monsanto permitted sed companies like Mahyco, Rasi, Ankur and Nuziveedu. It was called an indigenous Bt “variety” as distinct from the Monsanto hybrid where farmers have to buy fresh seeds each season. Farmers could re-use BN Bt cotton seeds for many years but within year then ICAR’s DDG S K Dutta, having received pressure from Agriculture Ministry stopped commercial sale of Bn Bt in 2009, hence we want Govt. Clarification recent developments and reports which exposes CICR activities as illegal and misleading to fact that Bt. Gen. where officially purchased by ICAR from Monsanto followed by baseless claims and counter claims of CICR Director Keshav Kranthi are mush more humiliating and creating doubts about integrality of CICR’’ Tiwari added.
‘In June 2009 to there was questions raised by vidarbha cotton farmers over CICR Director Keshav Kranthi claims that DESI Bt.cotton seed of CICR is beneficial in drought-tolerant, non-irrigated areas and is also resistant to sucking pests like jassids and aphids and VJAS had urged Indian Govt. to take official stand over this ICAR activity as our experience with Monsanto’s Bt,cotton seed is too bad to believe in any more Desi Bt.cotton seed as GM technology is based on gene which only available in part of America then it is must for Indian Govt. to clarify on the claims of CICR ” Kishore Tiwari further added.
Please release this pres note
Yours faithfully, For VIDARBHA JAN ANDOLAN SAMlTI